Provider Comparison

Looking to start self-directing your IRA funds? You'll find a side-side comparison of IRA Providers on this page. We've compared five of the top IRA providers for self-directed investments by taking information straight from provider forms and organizing in an easy to read format.

IRA Blogs Fee Scenarios

IRA Provider Comparison


New Direction IRA

Pensco Trust

Equity Trust

Lincoln Trust

Poly Comp
      Account Options
Traditional IRA X X X X X
Roth IRA X X X X X
SIMPLE IRA X X X X
Simplified Employee Pension (SEP) IRA X X X X X
Health Savings Account (HSA) X X X
401(k) X X X X
Individual(k) X X X X X
      Other account types that can be moved
403(b) X X X X X
457(Governmental) X X X X X
SARSEP X X X X X
      Investment Options
Real Estate X X X X X
LLC's
Trust Deeds X X X X X
Private Stock X X X X X
Certificates of Deposit (CDs) X X X X X
Traditional Securities: Stocks, Bonds, Mutual Funds, Options requires brokerage account X X X
Precious Metals X N/A X N/A X
Vehicles X X X X X
Mobile Homes X X X X X
Unsecured Notes X X X X X
Equipment Leases X X X X X
Foreign Exchange X X X X X
Commodities X X X X X
Tax Liens X X X X X
Other legally allowable investments X X X X X
      Company Info, Features, and Services
Year Established 2003 1989 1974 1962 1974
Number of Clients 4,000 N/A 140,000 N/A N/A
$$ in assets $360 million N/A $10 Billion N/A N/A
BBB Accreditation A+ Rating
0 complaints
A+ Rating
7 complaints
B- Rating
31 complaints
B Rating
Not Accredited
6 complaints
A Rating
Not Accredited
Bonded/Insured Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
FDIC Insured Yes X X Yes Yes
Access to Regular Educational/Networking Events Yes Yes N/A N/A Limited
Annual Tax Reporting X X X X X
Online Account Statements Yes N/A N/A N/A N/A
Live Workshops Yes Yes N/A N/A Yes
Online Learning Center IRA Learning Library Yes Yes Limited Limited
      Account Minimums
Account Minimums none N/A N/A $100,000 depends on assets held
      New Account Fees
Account Establishment $50 per new account $50 $50 $200 $95
      Annual (Recurring) Asset Holding Fees   Note: only one option applies per account.
Fee Based on Number of Assets held $295 per asset and/or Liability Variable + $200 annual fee $260 (first asset) + $100ea additional
Fee Based on Total Account Value $195-$1850
See Fee Schedule
$375 - No Limit
See Fee Schedule
$190-$1850
See Fee Schedule
based on asset qty
See Fee Schedule
based on asset qty
See Fee Schedule
Pg 10
All Inclusive Account $2,400 (family plan - no transaction costs except wire/overnight fees) N/A N/A N/A N/A
      Transaction Fees
Purchase, Sale, Exchange, or Re-Registration of any Asset (non real estate) $95 $0 $0 $150 $30-$150
Purchase, Sale, or Exchange of Real Estate $250 $0 $0 $150 $300
Purchase, Sale, or Exchange of Leveraged Real Estate $345 $0 $0 $150 $300
Wire Transfers $30 ea $30 ea $30 ea $25 ea outgoing $30 ea
incoming $10 ea
Cashiers or other Official Bank Check $30 ea $75 ea $10 ea $50 ea $75 ea
ACH Transfers, Trust Checks $5 ea $8 ea N/A ACH free, checks $10 N/A
Overnight Mail $30 $18 $18 $25 $25 minimum
Returned Items or Stop Payment Request $30 ea $30 ea N/A $50 ea $35 ea
Extraordinary Hourly Services $150/hr $75/hr N/A $50/hr, $100 minimum $150/hr
Account Termination (Partial) maximum $250 $100 $75 + $100/asset transferred N/A N/A
Account Termination (FULL) Maximum $250 (Includes asset transfer) $225 + $50 per asset $200 + $100/asset transferred $100 + asset reregistration ($75/asset + direct costs) $250 + $125/asset-($250 if real estate assets)